Sunday, June 10, 2018

TRUTH, CONSEQUENCES AND THE MODERN FISH ACT


For the past 15 months or so, anglers have been the targets of an intense, and intensively funded, public relations campaign that has urged them to support the Modernizing Recreational Fisheries Management Act, something that its supporters refer to bey the more appealing sobriquet of “The Modern Fish Act.”

Anglers’ rights groups implored their members to support the legislation, with the Recreational Fishing Alliance and the like-minded Coastal Conservation Association both praising the bill.


“One of the association’s main priorities is to see the Modern Fish Act become law.  This bipartisan bill will make long-overdue changes to improve federal marine fisheries management.  We need our entire industry to stand behind it and promote it to the recreational fishing public.  Our partner in the legislative effort, the Center for Sportfishing Policy, has developed a suite of digital tools that you an use on your websites and social media to bring awareness of this bill to your customers.  It’s time for recreational fishermen and our industry to speak up—help us expand this call to action.”


“Never has there been a more critical time to get involved in advocacy and attend the American Boating Congress.  In 2018, the recreational boating industry is facing major policy decisions that will come to a head this summer and have long-lasting impacts on boating in the U.S., including getting the Modern Fish Act passed…”

“It is critical we engage with our nation’s decision-makers now to shape legislative decisions in the coming months.  With so many key issues coming to a head this summer, it’s imperative that you attend this year’s American Boating Congress to help us address major policy decisions impacting your business…”


“Anglers of all backgrounds should be able to enjoy this great sport without limitation.  Although most of these efforts [to limit angling activities] the problems in saltwater today the problems in freshwater tomorrow.  [emphasis added]”

“The recreational fishing industry can flourish or fail based on decisions made in Washington, D.C.  Specifically, saltwater anglers continue to be misrepresented in major federal fisheries management policies.  And with one in every four anglers fishing in saltwater, that is too many Americans who cannot enjoy the great pastime of fishing due to dated fishery management.  Bass Anglers for Saltwater Conservation brings both saltwater and freshwater fishermen together to defend the sport we all love.  [emphasis added]”
To call that a simplistic explanation of important fisheries issues, with no honest discussion of the issues involved would be, if anything, an understatement.  So naturally visitors to that page are quickly directed to another that encourages them to support the Modern Fish Act.  Again, the reasoning is superficial”

“The Modern Fish Act is at a crucial stage, with votes approaching in both chambers of Congress.  However, we still need your voice to support this bill and the rights of recreational anglers.  Click below to send a letter urging your elected officials to support the Modern Fish Act.  [emphasis added]”
As I said, despite the name of the site, there isn’t a lot of conservation being promoted there.

And when we recognize that, we start to get closer to the truths underlying the Modern Fish Act.

Modern Fish Act supporters have long tried to disguise themselves by hiding under the mantle of conservation.  The American Sportfishing Association has claimed that

“It will improve access to America’s federal waters and promote conservation of our natural marine resources,”
although how greater “access”—which, in the Modern Fish Act context, always means more dead fish, as there is no bar to anglers merely venturing into federal waters, and so “accessing” them, today—will promote conservation is never exactly explained.


“We are proud to Work with Members of Congress on both sides of the aisle to advance a common-sense policy that remains true to our conservation goals while promoting access to our healthy natural resources.”
The latter quote was reprinted on On the Water magazine’s website, and immediately drew a response from a reader who said

“Shame on OTW for this ‘article.’  Don’t believe this garbage for a second.  This act is being pushed through by companies trying to sell more boats.  The results will be loopholes that allow overfishing and stocks will collapse…”
While I disagree with that reader’s first sentence—I’m a strong supporter of the First Amendment, and believe that a publication has the right to publish anything that it wishes, so long as it’s not defamatory, and further believe that a reputable publication, which I consider On the Water to be, has an obligation to acknowledge many differing viewpoints—I think that the rest of that comment pretty well captures the rarely-spoken truth about why folks are trying so hard to get the Modern Fish Act passed.

And truth, as they say, will out.


“These amendments need to not only support the existing populations of recreational anglers and fishing related businesses but also allow new entrants to come into the fishery and businesses to grow and expand. 
“The law needs to recognize that in its current form, our tradition of fishing cannot be passed onto our children without [the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act] taking away opportunity from the rest of the fishing community.”
It wouldn’t be at all unreasonable to interpret that statement to mean that the intent behind the Modern Fish Act isn’t to better conserve and manage fish stocks, as the Act’s supporters often say, but to provide a bigger pool of dead fish to support an increase in the number of fishermen, and a related increase in the size, number—and profits—of fishing related businesses.

In fact, it’s hard to interpret such statement in any other way.
Such an interpretation finds support in a number of recent comments made by leading members of the boatbuilding industry.


“Today’s system of fisheries management is outdated, and hampering access for our nation’s recreational anglers.  People won’t purchase boats and equipment if they see no reason to get out on the water…  [emphasis added]”
From that, NMMA’s reasons for supporting the Modern Fish Act seem pretty clear.  And conservation isn’t among them…

This week, two other pieces authored by boating industry insiders came out, in support of the Act.  One was written by John Pfeiffer, President of Mercury Marine, which is headquartered in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin.  Writing in the Kenosha (WI) News, Mr. Pfeiffer noted that

“Under Magnuson-Stevens as currently written, the federal government tries to manage a family on a day-trip the same way they it manages commercial fishermen who fill their holds with thousands of fish.  The failure to make a clear distinction between the two pursuits makes little sense and stunts the growth of the American sportfishing and boating industries…
“While Wisconsinites mainly fish in fresh water, we’re excited about the Modern Fish Act.  By updating and improving saltwater fisheries management, the recreational fishing industry would grow, creating more demand for boats and marine accessories like those we manufacture and sell at Mercury Marine…    [emphasis added]”
There’s that “let’s kill more fish so we can expand our business” thing again…


“Recreational fishing matters to hundreds of Connecticut marine businesses, including mine.”
Taken together, it’s all pretty clear.  The Modern Fish Act has nothing to do with conservation.  The truth is, it’s all about the bottom line.

The interesting thing is that, when people learn the truth, it has consequences.


The Galveston County Daily News has reported that “Charter groups dump Yamaha motors over lobbying.”  {Unfortunately, the story is behind a pay wall, but anyone who wants to confirm the headline, or pay to read the whole thing, can click on this link.)

According to the Daily News,

“About a dozen local charter company boat captains so far have sold their Yamaha motors and replaced them with different brands to protest the Yamaha Motor Co., a multinational company based in Japan that makes and sells outboard motors and boats, among other products.
“The company has advocated for changes to the federal fishing management law that would roll back some of the principals [sic] that helped rebuild once-depleted fisheries and lead to unsustainable practices, said Scott Hickman, owner of Circle H Outfitters, a charter fishing company.”
Capt. Hickman reportedly said that

“We had turned the corner and rebuilt these fisheries.  Now, companies like Yamaha are funding bad legislation that would roll back the conservation aspects of the act.”
Yamaha, not unsurprisingly, denies doing anything that would harm fish stocks, but has admitted that

“The company pushed for the changes because they would update how data is collected about the fishery and extend recreational seasons, which is good for business.  [emphasis added]”
But extended recreational seasons aren’t necessarily good for the fish.  As the Daily News article notes,

“Mike Short, a Galveston captain who owns Get Hooked Charters, removed the Yamaha motors on several of his boats in protest of the company’s lobbying.  Short supported longer recreational seasons, but thought recreational anglers should be held to enforcement standards for catch limits like other sectors, he said.
“’Yamaha is sticking its nose where it shouldn’t,’ Short said.  ‘Their job is to build and sell motors.  There’s plenty of fish out there, they just need to let the government do what they do to manage the fishery.’”
Change “Yamaha” to “fishing and boating trade groups, as a whole,” and he’s pretty well said it all.






Thursday, June 7, 2018

TIME TO HELP OUT THE HERRING--AND THEIR PREDATORS


Sometimes it seems that too many people, including fishery managers, forget that fish have to eat.

Thus, we get high-volume fisheries for forage species, the low trophic level fish that feed largely on plankton and, in turn, serve as food for everything else in the sea.  

For far too long, those who manage such fisheries have remained focused only on maintaining the sustainability of the forage fish harvest, and spend too little time focusing on the importance of such forage species to both larger predators and to the fisheries that such predators support.

That is slowly beginning to change.



As the Draft Amendment notes,

“Atlantic herring have supported an important commercial fishery since the late 19th century and play a very important role in the ecosystem as forage fish for many predators including marine mammals, larger fish, and seabirds, which support additional commercial, recreational and ecotourism industries…
“The primary purpose of Amendment 8 is to modify the fishery management plan for Atlantic herring fishery by:
1.        Proposing a long-term acceptable biological catch (ABC) control rule for the Atlantic herring fishery that may explicitly account for herring’s role in the ecosystem and to address the biological and ecological requirements of the Atlantic herring resource.
2.       Proposing measures to address potential localized depletion of Atlantic herring to minimize possible detrimental biological impacts on predators of herring and associated socioeconomic impacts on other user groups.”

With regard to such localized depletion, the Draft Amendment states that

“Localized depletion occurs when harvesting takes more fish than can be replaced either locally or through fish migrating into the catch area within a given time period.”
The Draft Amendment provides additional detail by including a “Council Problem Statement” that says

“Scoping comments for Amendment 8 identified concerns with concentrated, intense commercial fishing for Atlantic herring in specific areas and at certain times that may cause detrimental socioeconomic impacts on other user groups (commercial, recreational, ecotourism) who depend upon adequate local availability of Atlantic herring to support business and recreational interests both at sea and on shore.  The Council intends to further explore these concerns through examination of the best available science on localized depletion, the spatial nature of the fisheries, reported conflicts among users of the resources and the concerns of the herring fishery and other stakeholders.”
In other words, the problem is not a shortage of herring, at least if the current biomass is evaluated on a single-species, rather than on an ecosystem, basis.  Although the stock is managed very aggressively and with a minimum of precaution—the total allowable catch for 2018 is set so high that there is a 50-50 chance that overfishing will occur—the most recent operational stock assessment, conducted in 2015, found that spawning stock biomass was well over the target level, while fishing mortality was well below the overfishing threshold in 2014.


“Our guys are not fishing the way they did 12 years ago around the Cape because those fish aren’t there because the bait isn’t there.  We live in a migratory corridor here.  We depend on the bait to be there.”

“Mid-water trawlers are breaking our local food web by removing millions of pounds of herring and in turn harming everything from cod fishermen to whale boat operators.  The residents of Cape Cod feel the effects of sea and river herring being taken from nearshore waters, are penalized for harvesting, possessing or selling it, yet the industrial fleets are not.
“They can legally catch hundreds of thousands of pounds of river herring that are tossed overboard dead.  Predators (striped bass, cod, tuna) leave our area because they don’t have enough to eat.  We think this is the most important offshore issue facing us now.”
There are thus a lot of voices calling for the New England Council to push the big herring trawlers further offshore.  


In Rhode Island, anglers are strongly supporting options in the Draft Amendment that would consider Atlantic herring’s role in the ecosystem when setting catch limits, and push the mid-water trawlers at least 25 miles offshore.  


“For Rhode Island a 25 mile buffer is important to help prevent localized depletion and user conflicts considering the major role herring plays around Block Island and Cox Ledge as forage fish for striped bass, cod, tuna, whales and other species.”
Conservation groups are also pushing for recognition of Atlantic herring’s importance as a forage fish, and for inshore buffers that exclude the mid-water trawlers.  

The Conservation Law Foundation, Wild Oceans and the National Audubon Society, among others, are asking that the big trawlers be pushed at least 50 miles offshore, to provide an adequate feeding corridor for the herring’s predators.

Not surprisingly, about the only opposition to managing herring as forage fish, and to creating the no-mid-water trawler buffer zone, comes from a group that disingenuously calls itself the “Sustainable Fisheries Coalition,” and describes itself as

“an organization of the Atlantic herring and Atlantic mackerel mid-water trawl and purse seine industry, operating from Maine through New Jersey.  The Coalition was established in 2007 to improve public outreach and education and increase awareness of the economic importance environmental sustainability of the Atlantic herring and Atlantic mackerel fisheries.”

“said in an email the current control rule [which ignores the Atlantic herring’s role in the ecosystem] is better because it allows for more flexibility in setting catch limits,”
and

“opposes any new restrictions because they claim there is no evidence that current regulations are harming herring.”
Of course, that latter comment ignores the whole point of ecosystem-based management—it’s not about not harming the targeted species, but about not harming the entire ecosystem within which the targeted species functions—but it’s about what you can expect from a group that specializes in removing many, many tons of forage fish from the ocean each year.

The very last thing they want anyone thinking about is their impact on the ecosystem…

But for those who believe that the health of the ecosystem matters, time is getting short.  The New England Fishery Management Council will be accepting comments on Draft Amendment 8 through 5:00 p.m. on Monday, June 25. 

Such comments should be addressed to Thomas A. Nies, Executive Director, New England Fishery Management Council, 50 Water Street, Mill 2, Newburyport, MA  01950.  If sent by mail, comments should be sent early enough that they are received by the June 25 deadline.  

Given the uncertainties of mail delivery, it might make more sense to email all comments to comments@nefmc.org, or fax them to 978-465-3116.

To make sure that all comments are sent to the right place, they should state “DEIS for Amendment 8 to the Atlantic Herring FMP” on the message line of all emails or elsewhere on mailed or faxed correspondence.

And if folks are concerned about a healthy ecosystem and forage fish stock, all comments relating to setting an Acceptable Biological Catch control rule should support Alternative 2, which

“would prioritize herring predator forage needs based on limiting fishing mortality to 50% of [fishing mortality at maximum sustainable yield],”
and with respect to potential localized depletion and user conflicts, either Alternative 5 (25-mile buffer) or Alternative 6 (50-mile buffer) to keep the mid-water trawls offshore and better assure that predators in nearshore waters will find enough herring to provide for their forage fish needs.

Of course, the Sustainable Fisheries Coalition—the folks who tow those big mid-water trawls—hope that no one does that sort of thing.

Which should be enough to get you off of your couch and onto your keyboard, to make sure that your comments are heard.






Sunday, June 3, 2018

BIG CHANGE COMING IN RECREATIONAL LANDINGS DATA


For many years, anglers and businesses critical of recreational fishing regulations have focused their ire on the Marine Recreational Fisheries Statistics Survey (MRFSS) and on MRFSS’ successor, the Marine Recreational Information Program(MRIP), claiming that the landings estimates those surveys produced were very inaccurate and did not truly reflect recreational harvest.

Their criticisms of MRFSS found some support in a 2006 study, Review of Recreational Fisheries Survey Methods, which was conducted by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS). It determined that “Both the telephone and access components of [MRFSS] have serious flaws in design or implementation and use inadequate analysis methods that need to be *addressed immediately.”

The NAS study’s findings caused the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) to develop MRIP, a program designed to provide much more accurate estimates of recreational harvest.

A NAS review of MRIP, released early in 2017, declared that NMFS had made “significant improvements in gathering information through redesigned surveys, strengthening the quality of data.” Although MRIP represents a big jump forward in recreational data collection, the NAS report noted that “some challenges remain, such as incorporating technological advances for data collection and enhancing communication with anglers and some other stakeholders.”

That wasn’t the news that some anglers’ rights organizations wanted to hear. They had long opposed NMFS’ regulations by arguing that the harvest data underlying such rules were bad. Thus, they tried to spin NAS’ generally favorable report, distorting its message in an attempt to argue that MRIP data, too, was unreliable. The overall thrust of their message was that MRFFS, and now MRIP, provided estimates that overstated recreational harvest, and led to unnecessarily restrictive regulations.

On or about July 2, 2018, those organizations, and the people who believed their message, will be very disappointed, as that is when NMFS plans to announce new data that will demonstrate that MRFSS and MRIP catch estimates actually underestimatedrecreational harvest to a very significant degree.

To understand why that’s the case, it’s important to first understand how recreational catch estimates are made.
MRIP is actually comprises two different surveys. Data related to what anglers’ catch is gleaned from the Access-Point Angler Intercept Survey, in which anglers are interviewed at randomly selected private-boat docks, boat liveries and shore-fishing spots (anglers fishing from party and charter boats have their catch information recorded in a separate For-Hire Survey), where their catch can be identified, counted and measured.

Information on how often anglers go fishing is generated by a separate survey. For many years, that was the so-called Coastal Household Telephone Survey (CHTS), which employed random-digit dialing to call households in coastal counties, determine whether anyone in that household fished and, if they did, determine how many salt water fishing trips they had made in the previous two months.

The calculated mean catch per interviewed angler was then multiplied by the estimated number of trips made; the product of those two numbers was the estimated recreational landings for each two-month “wave.”

Studies conducted in recent years have revealed that the CHTS was significantly flawed, and that replacing it with a mail survey would allow surveyors to reach more anglers, achieve higher response rates and eliminate much of the error caused when anglers misremembered the number of trips they actually made. Such studies determined that effort by private boat anglers is 2.9 times higher, and effort by shore-based anglers is 5.9 times higher, than the CHTS suggested.

That means that the actual recreational harvest was much higher than previously estimated, too, although precisely how much higher will depend upon the particular fishery, the state where the survey occurred and the time of year when each survey was made.
Many anglers may immediately fear that higher estimates of recreational harvest will lead to increased restrictions on anglers. While that may be true in some cases, the actual impact of the updated estimates will vary from stock to stock. Dr. Ned Cyr, Director of the Office of Science and Technology for NMFS, has noted that “the first step is to incorporate the calibrated data into stock assessments,” and that “recreational effort and catch estimates are just two factors” that go into such assessments.

Once that’s done, according to Dr. Cyr, “We anticipate that those stocks with a higher proportion of recreational fishing could potentially see larger impacts such as changes to stock status, annual catch limits, and possibly allocations, depending on council actions.” He acknowledged that the new estimates could impact stock assessments that are conducted as early as the second half of 2018.
That means that things on the management front are about to get very interesting, as stock assessments for some important and often controversial recreational species, including summer flounder, striped bass and Atlantic cobia are scheduled for late this year. There are also some pending management actions that could be very significantly impacted by the new numbers.
From an angler’s standpoint, summer flounder may prove to be the most interesting case. The stock, once badly overexploited, has since recovered, although it has never achieved the biomass target. Overfishing has occurred in recent years, largely due to consecutive years of below-average spawning success leading to a sharp decline in abundance. Add in increased angling effort, and so an increased recreational harvest, and many things might occur.

The first thing that may well happen is that the higher estimates of recreational harvest will force fishery managers to revise the size of the fluke population upward.

That might seem counterintuitive to many fishermen, who would think that any data showing that more fish had been landed would also show that there were fewer fish left in the sea. But that’s not exactly how population models work.
Biologists often estimate the size of fish populations by employing a technique known as “virtual population analysis” (VPA). It works much like a bank account, using estimates of income (fish recruited into the population) and expenses (fish removed from the population by fishing or natural mortality) to determine population size. But there’s a twist to VPAs, in that the size of a fish population is calculated backwards. That is, biologists use the number of fish caught, combined with estimates of recruitment and natural mortality, to determine how large a population must have been in the past to support the known volume of landings.

Thus, if the revised harvest estimates show that anglers caught more summer flounder than biologists had originally believed, such higher landings would imply that the population must also have been larger than previously thought. Otherwise, the population wouldn’t have been able to support such a high level of landings for as many years as it had.
That reassessment of the population size could, in turn, also lead to a corresponding increase in the annual catch limit. At the same time, daily bag limits, or other regulations, could become more restrictive, to account for the higher estimates of recreational effort.
Both allocation and any new regulations could also be affected by a change in the way fish are allocated. The current allocation, which grants 40% of the overall catch limit to the recreational sector and 60% to commercial fishermen, was based on harvest estimates for the years 1980-1989. Should revised effort data lead to significantly higher recreational harvest estimates for those years, it is likely that representatives of the recreational fishing sector will push the Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council(MAFMC) to revise the allocation accordingly. However, there is no guarantee that any such revision would be adopted; allocation debates are notoriously bitter and divisive, and rarely result in significant change, even when the objective evidence for such change seems strong.

Updated effort and landings estimates might be more successfully used to prevent the reallocation of bluefish from the recreational to the commercial sector.
The MAFMC, acting in conjunction with the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC), have recently initiated an amendment to the bluefish management plan, which contemplates just such an action, based on the belief that anglers have not been harvesting their full bluefish quota while, at the same time, commercial fishermen are seeking ways to increase their landings. Should the updated data demonstrate that anglers are landing more bluefish than fishery managers had believed, as appears almost certain, the rationale for any such reallocation would be undermined.
Increased estimates of recreational harvest, arising out of the revised effort data, may also have a significant impact on the striped bass debate now unfolding at the ASMFC.
The objectives of ASMFC’s current striped bass management plan include, among others, to “Manage fishing mortality to maintain an age structure that provides adequate spawning potential to sustain long-term abundance of striped bass populations,” and “Establish a fishing mortality target that will result in a net increase in the abundance (pounds) of age 15 and older striped bass in the population, relative to the 2000 estimate.”

Such objectives require a relatively conservative management approach, but at a recent meeting of ASMFC’s Striped Bass Management Board (Management Board), some Management Board members argued that current management measures were too conservative.

At the following meeting, the Management Board instructed the biologists performing the upcoming stock assessment to consider a range of management options, including those that would allow a higher level of striped bass harvest, and a relaxation of current regulations.

If updated estimates reveal that recreational striped bass harvest, which already accounts for more than two-thirds of all striped bass landings, is much higher than the Management Board had thought, current management may be far less conservative than previously believed, making it more difficult to justify further relaxing existing regulations.

Thus, there are many possible implications of the upcoming release of revised recreational effort and landings data. While the new and more accurate data will permit more effective regulation and management of salt water fish stocks, and allow fishery managers to better ensure such stocks’ long-term health, it is impossible to predict precisely what impact they will have on any particular fishery.
But it is easy to predict that some things will change.
-----

This essay first appeared in “From the Waterfront,” the blog of the Marine Fish Conservation Network, which can be found at http://conservefish.org/blog/

Thursday, May 31, 2018

RIGHT MESSAGE, WRONG REASON


I was thumbing through the pages of Billfish Magazine, the in-house publication of The Billfish Foundation, when a small article caught my eye.

It was titled “Fishing outside the U.S. might bite you upon returning,” explained how international agreements limit U.S. recreational landings of Atlantic marlins (blue and white combined) to just 250 fish, and warned boat owners who hold Highly Migratory Species permits that such limit applies to their catch even when fishing in the waters of another nation or on the high seas.

It further advised that

“If U.S. vessels are responsible for landing more than 250 Atlantic marlin [overseas] or in U.S. waters, all billfishing in U.S. waters and by U.S. vessels, whether in a tournament or not, will be switched to a release format.  If the number significantly exceeds 250, the all-release format could be extended for more than 12 months.”
The piece specifically mentioned fish caught in the Dominican Republic, which made sense because, as noted elsewhere in the magazine, some U.S. sportfishing boats staging out of Dominican ports and fishing around Dominican fish aggregating devices have gotten into conflicts with local commercial fishermen, who view them as competition for the billfish resource.  The U.S. boats have resolved such conflicts by allowing the locals to gaff and retain the sport-caught marlin, which apparently made the Dominican fishermen happy, but created the regulatory issue described above when they ended up killing too many marlin.

Billfish Magazine went on to note that a lot of the marlin caught in such fashion are small, meaning that the U.S. boats may be literally robbing the nursery when they catch the fish and let the locals kill them.

That should be reason enough to stop the practice. 


But it wasn’t the reason The Billfish Foundation gave.  

Instead, it warned

“BOAT OWNERS:  If you desire to fish “big money” tournaments in U.S. waters, make very clear with your team that landing Atlantic marlin or handing a hooked one off to a local may eliminate your opportunity to win a large tournament purse in the U.S…
“If the big money U.S. tournament purses for the largest Atlantic marlin are important to you, its best to catch, resuscitate, and release each billfish when fishing in other nations’ waters.  Protect your option to win the big purse at home by helping to keep the number of Atlantic marlin landed in all waters to a minimum.”
In other words, don’t release the marlin you catch somewhere else because it’s the right thing to do for the stock.  Don’t do it because it’s probably the only way that your kid or your grandkid might be able to catch their own billfish someday.  Instead, release the marlin you catch off other nations’ shores to preserve your ability to kill marlin over here, so you can show them off at the dock, maybe collect a tournament purse, and leave them to rot in an American dumpster…

Not a very nice message when put it in those words.

Yet I don’t blame The Billfish Foundation for using the language they did.  They’re one of the better organizations out there, dedicated to using the best science available—or paying the tab to develop needed science when it’s not available—and an advocate for better billfish conservation. 

I was a member for about 25 years; not one of the high-roller members that keeps the organization alive, but just one of the minor contributors who might have kept the office air conditioning running for a few hours each year.  I joined out of guilt after I put one of my anglers on a first-place white marlin in a kill tournament back in 1990 (for the record, that fish was eaten, not thrown away), but stuck around because I liked the work that the foundation was doing.  I’m no longer a member because of their support for the Modern Fish Act, but should they ever rethink that position, I’d likely join again.

In issuing their recent warning, I suspect that The Billfish Foundation was just trying to appeal to the mindset of big-boat tournament anglers, and trying to get them to do the right thing.  

I’ve been fishing offshore for many years, and went through my tournament phase; I fully understand the bravado, the sort of “Look at ME!” “Mine is bigger than yours” attitudes that afflict today’s big-boat tournament crowd.

Tell them that their actions are hurting marlin populations, and many will laugh in your face.  Tell them that they might not be able to pose in tournament photos with a dead marlin, their girlfriends and a horde of hungry flies, or collect a big tournament check, and they’ll listen and start getting serious.

And that’s too bad.  But it’s what happens when cash, and not fish, become the center of tournament efforts.

It wasn’t always that way.

In what some call the “Golden Age” of salt water fishing, the years immediately before and after the Second World War, fishing tournaments were all about sportsmanship and big fish, and not about money at all. 



“In the 1930s, two fishing clubs located roughly 34 miles apart threw down the gauntlet for giant bluefin tuna bragging rights in a two-boat-only event that featured a team from Freeport, New York, and one from Manasquan, New Jersey.  Without giant dock parties and fanfare, captain’s meetings, or beer sponsors, the two teams fished head-to-head and exchanged their catch weights via a landline telephone.  Tournament tuna fishing had begun.
“Getting an invite to compete in the USATT and a chance to catch giants was a highly sought after prize for anglers.”
As one angler quoted in the article said,

“In comparison with today’s tournaments, the USATT was much different.  It wasn’t commercial, we fished for trophies and bragging rights.  No prize money was involved, it was all about honor.”
All about honor.

We could use some of that honor in our fishing these days. 

Then maybe we wouldn’t need lie detectors to test tournament winners.  



And The Billfish Foundation wouldn’t have had to make releasing Atlantic marlin all about money, when it’s already the right thing to do.


Sunday, May 27, 2018

MOVING THE GOALPOSTS


The National Marine Fisheries Service released its latest report on the state of America’s fisheries, and the news was good.  Thanks to the effective management measures imposed by the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, the number of overfished stocks has been whittled down to just 35, while the number of stocks subject to overfishing is now only 30.

Six stocks were removed from the “overfishing” list, and six from the “overfished” list.  Only one stock, Georges Bank winter flounder, was removed from both, meaning that eleven separate stocks showed real improvement in their status over the course of the past year.

That sounds pretty good, and it’s even almost true.  But the fact of the matter is that while eight federally-managed stocks really did improve their status, in the case of three others, the improvement was due less to biology, meaning a real increase in abundance or decrease in fishing mortality, and more to bureaucracy and the way NMFS determines stock status.

Witch flounder provide the clearest example.  The stock is unquestionably overfished, and managers previously determined that overfishing was occurring.  However, a 2017 update to the witch flounder stock assessment found that

“stock status is overfished and overfishing is unknown due to a lack of biological reference points…  [emphasis added]”
In other words, witch flounder were not taken off the “overfishing” list because overfishing had ended, but because biologists lack enough information to determine whether the stock is suffering from overfishing or not.

The situation with Western Atlantic bluefin tuna is similar, if a bit more complicated by debates over age at maturity, a possible decline in the stock’s recruitment potential and the rate if mixing between the Western Atlantic and Eastern Atlantic stocks.  Still, the Western Atlantic bluefin’s removal from the “overfished” list can be attributed primarily to a 2017 bluefin tuna stock assessment conducted by the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas, which determined that there was insufficient information available to determine the current status of that stock.

Thus, the removal of both witch flounder and Western Atlantic Bluefin tuna from the “overfishing” and “overfished” stocks, respectively, merely represent NMFS’ recognition of the fact that there is insufficient information available to make a determination as to stock status.  Such removal represents admirable intellectual honesty, although listing both stocks among others that have truly shown signs of improvement, in a generally upbeat press release, is a sort of bureaucratic red herring and agency puffery that suggests that the progress made in conserving fish stocks was somewhat greater than it actually was.

Even such semi-kind words can’t be said about the removal of Gulf of Mexico red snapper and gray triggerfish from the “overfished” list, which was more a feat of political legerdemain than of any sort of management prowess.

That bit of slight-of-hand was achieved through a document known as Amendment 44 to the Fishery Management Plan for the Reef Fish Resources of the Gulf of Mexico, also titled Minimum Stock Size Threshold (MSST) Revision for Reef Fish Stocks with Existing Status Determination Criteria.

For many years, Gulf red snapper and gray triggerfish, along with five other species, were managed using a minimum stock size threshold—that is, the threshold used to determine when a stock was overfished—that was calculated using each stock’s natural mortality rate and the biomass needed to produce maximum sustainable yield.  Both the red snapper and gray triggerfish stocks were deemed to be overfished pursuant to such criteria.

Their answer was Amendment 44, which replaced the science-based minimum stock size threshold with a politically pragmatic one, adopting a new threshold of 50% of the biomass needed to produce maximum sustainable yield for all seven species, most particularly including red snapper. 

It’s possible that any such effort would have failed in previous years, when the seats on the Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council were relatively balanced between state fishery managers, commercial fishermen, for-hire boatmen and recreational interests.  But 2017 appointments to that council favored the recreational sector, which was proud to announce that, in making such council appointments, the

by appointing their favored candidates.  Such additional recreational appointees, when teamed with existing anglers already sitting on the council and state managers who often sided with the well-heeled and politically active anglers’ rights organizations, allowed the blatantly political measure to get a favorable vote.

It should be noted that for some species, including red snapper, the original science-based thresholds may have presented a practical problem; Amendment 44 notes that

“The need for the proposed action is to provide a wide enough buffer between spawning stock biomass at maximum sustainable yield (BMSY) and [Minimum Spawning Stock Threshold], particularly for stocks with low natural mortality rates, to prevent stocks from frequently alternating between overfished and rebuilt conditions due to natural variation in recruitment and other environmental factor.”
That’s not an unreasonable concern, and could arguably justify a small reduction in the threshold to prevent frequent swings in the deemed state of certain stocks.  However, it should be noted that early drafts of Amendment 44 contained six possible alternatives, including thresholds equal to 75% and 85% of biomass at maximum sustainable yield.  At least one of those proposals should have provided buffers large enough to prevent frequent flip-flops between a stock being deemed “overfished” in one season, “rebuilt” a year or two later, and “overfished” a few years after that.

Instead, the recreationally-dominated Gulf Council elected to set the threshold at just 50% of biomass at maximum sustainable yield, which the environmental impact statement incorporated into the final version of Amendment 44 notes

“is the lowest [Minimum Stock Size Threshold] allowed under the National Standard 1 guidelines.  Relative to the other alternatives, this would result in the lowest likelihood of a stock being declared overfished, and would therefore be expected to have a greatest negative impact to the physical environment,”
and also

“the greatest negative impacts on the biological/ecological environment…”
On the other hand, the 50% threshold provided the only alternative that would take red snapper and gray triggerfish off the overfished list, and the only one that could prevent massive red snapper paybacks in subsequent seasons.

Thus, despite its potentially negative impacts on the physical, biological and ecological environments of the Gulf of Mexico, it was the alternative that the recreational representatives on the Gulf Council heartily endorsed.  (It should be noted that Amendment 44 was well underway before the 2017 red snapper season was reopened, and before the extremely high level of recreational overharvest in 2017 was confirmed.  However, the effort to increase Gulf recreational red snapper harvest, which culminated in the reopened season, had also been underway for a very long time, and it would thus be disingenuous to suggest that Amendment 44 wasn’t seen as a tool to avoid recreational paybacks being used as a means to hold anglers accountable for their continual excess overharvest.)

NMFS declaring any sort of victory because Gulf red snapper and Gulf gray triggerfish have been taken off the “overfished” list is akin to a football team claiming two touchdowns just because they had possession of the ball on the opposing team’s 45-yard line—you only need to look at some of the rhetoric of the anglers’ rights crowd to understand that they very much consider federal fishery managers to be the “opposing team”—and then managed to somehow have the goalposts moved from the end zone out to mid-field. 

Any so-called “success” wasn’t do to moving the ball forward—in the case of red snapper, the illegal 2017 season reopening probably moved the “ball” back a yard or two—but to moving the goal posts so far from where they belonged that such “touchdowns” required no effort at all.

Even with red snapper and triggerfish out of the picture, and considering the uncertainty that plagues witch flounder and bluefin tuna, 2017 represents a real victory for fisheries management and for the Magnuson-Stevens Act, as five stocks really were no longer subject to overfishing, and three were, from a biological standpoint, no longer overfished.

Still, in the future, we should be careful to assure that any claimed victories truly involve advancing the health and abundance of managed fish stocks, and not by merely allowing our goals to retreat to levels that no longer hold meaning.