Thursday, November 19, 2026

"POOR FISHING...A HUGE TOLL ON THE BOTTOM LINE"

 

It was a small shop, taking up half of the ground floor of a very modest building located on the southwest corner of West Putnam Avenue and River Road in the Cos Cob section of Greenwich, Connecticut.  But it entranced me back in the days when my age could be expressed with a single digit, and my father and I would stop by to buy bait on the way back from church on summer Sunday mornings back in the early 1960s.

Time moved on, I grew older, and the shop eventually grew larger, moving diagonally across the intersection to the northeast corner, where it shared a parking lot with the Mianus River dam, and sold hundreds of dip nets each spring to the folks who came out of New York City each spring to catch the river herring trying to ascend the river to spawn. 

By then, I was old enough to walk to the shop, and down to the adjacent river to go fishing on my own.  I liked to cast for striped bass and bluefish, and remember how the shop’s owner used to take the Rebel plugs—then one of the more popular striped bass lures—out of their boxes and hang them from wires in a display case, along with their 95-cent price tag.

Yes, that was a long time ago.

Eventually, a new owner took over the shop.  By then, I was entering college, cutting lawns and doing light landscaping during the summer, but when a seasonal job opened up at the store, I was quick to take it.  The job and I fit each other well.  I was on the water just about every morning, and with the shop just five minutes from my boat, I could come in from fishing and go straight to work, and if I had a little blood or slime on my clothes, or smelled a little bit fishy, it just gave me a that much more credibility with the customers, many of whom weren’t experienced anglers and sometimes doubted that there were really any fish in our end of Long Island Sound.

Those years also gave me my first introduction to fisheries conservation and management, and some of the political problems that continue right up through today.  Striped bass fishing was extremely good throughout most of the 1970s.  Through at least the first half of the decade, there were plenty of smaller fish, but there were also a lot of large ones, with 40-pound bass being weighed at the shop on a regular basis, and even bigger fish far from scarce.  I still recall breaking the 50-pound mark on July 10, 1974, and feeling really proud and cocky about it for about 48 hours, before my fish was completely eclipsed by a kid barely into his teens who came in with a 63.  It was probably the most balanced fishery, in terms of varied fish sizes, I have ever seen in my life.

But by the second half of the decade, we started to notice fewer and fewer smaller fish in the mix.  One day, I was alone in the shop when an older man walked in with a big cardboard box under one arm.  He turned out to be Bob Pond, creator of the Atom line of striped bass lures, which were some of the best-known plugs, particularly among surfcasters, produced at that time.

We started talking, and it turned out that he was concerned that the number of juvenile striped bass being produced in the Chesapeake Bay was declining and that the bass population might be headed for a serious crash.  The cause of the recent poor spawns was, at that point, unknown, but he thought that it might be some sort of pollution, so the box that he carried into the store contained an array of labeled jars that he hoped our customers would fill with the reproductive organs of striped bass of both sexes and various sizes—all specified on the jars’ labels—so that he might have them tested for possible contaminants.

The story he told seemed to fit what I was seeing on the water, and I began getting involved with striped bass conservation and management issues, to the great displeasure of the shop’s owner.  He thought that conservation efforts might turn off his customers and hurt his income stream, and didn’t want me talking about the topic to anyone walking into the store.  When I did—I was never much good at taking directions that I believed were wrong—he would often start ranting and telling the customers that nothing was wrong with the striped bass stock.  “Everything’s fine!  There’s lots of bass!  Go out there and catch them and bring them back to the store!  We’ll weigh them in and put your picture up on the wall.”

Of course, history tells us that Bob Pond was right, and the bass stock was at the brink of a collapse that occurred just a few years later.  Although long before that happened, the shop owner and I parted ways on less than friendly terms. 

Almost 50 years later, when striped bass conservation and harvest reductions are discussed, we still hear shop owners fighting needed management measures simply because they’re bad for business in the short term, with little thought for what long-term harm the status quo might do.  That sort of thinking probably reached its apex last year, when the American Sportfishing Association, the tackle industry’s largest trade group, opposed a proposed 12% reduction in striped bass landings that was needed to ensure that the stock would be rebuilt in accordance with the management plan, and did so purely for short-term economic reasons.

Hopefully, history won’t repeat itself in the immediate future.

At any rate, the shop owner I had worked for eventually sold out to two other folks, who sold out in turn to someone else, who moved the shop down the road half a mile or so, to a marina on the Mianus River.  It was a wonderful spot, on a river lined with marinas and many hundreds of boats, and the shop thrived there for many years.

I had moved out of town in ’83, and so was never a regular customer of the store at the new location, although I stopped by a few times when I came back to town to fish with a friend who still keeps his boat on the river.  Despite my rocky relationship with one of its past owners, the shop was an institution among local anglers, and played a pretty big role in the first 25 years of my life, so I was a little dismayed to learn, just a week ago, that the store I had known for more than 60 years was going to go out of business.

The store’s owner said that he was leaving the business because it was hard to compete with online retailers, and because he wanted to spend more time with his family.  But he also said that he was leaving because of

“poor fishing.  It might sound like whining, but having a couple of years of poor fishing takes a huge toll on the bottom line in a small tackle shop.”

And fishing has, indeed, been poor in the western Long Island Sound in recent years.  It has been particularly poor when compared to the years when I still lived in Connecticut, but it has even been poor compared to just three or four years ago, too, and even then, the fishing wasn’t really all that good.

In some ways, I think of the mid-1970s as a sort of “Golden Age” of fishing in the western Sound.  Winter flounder and blackfish (tautog) were still abundant.  The striped bass decline hadn’t yet set in, and bluefish, including many in the mid-teens, were everywhere.  There were weakfish around, and fluke were beginning to establish themselves as a reliable target.  Atlantic mackerel could be caught by the hundreds every spring.

When I worked in the shop, bottom fishermen could by a flat (10 dozen) of sandworms and fill a bucket with flounder and porgies (scup), with perhaps a blackfish or two, maybe a blowfish (northern puffer) and the occasional black sea bass to keep things interesting.

At the same time, those who had fished in the decades before knew that a part of the picture was already missing.  The smelt fishery, which began in late October and ran until the creeks froze over in late December or January, had completely collapsed; the scores of fishermen who once lit up the docks every night with their Coleman lanterns, and supported the shop with steady purchases of bloodworms, hooks, cane poles, and such, during the slow selling period before the Christmas buying rush was no longer buying anything.  And tomcod, which we once caught in abundance while fishing for smelt and flounder seemed to be headed the same way.

Slowly, the fishing declined, and people got a lesson in what the “shifting baseline syndrome” really looked like.  At some point during the season, there might be decent fishing for one fish or another—maybe fluke, maybe bluefish, maybe porgies or striped bass.  Even though that fishing wasn’t quite as good as what anglers had experienced a decade or two before, it was the best they had seen in a while, so they started calling it “good” while forgetting what good fishing really looked like.

We saw the striped bass stock collapse, until only a few of us chased the remaining unicorns, but with huge bluefish blitzing in the harbors every morning from late May into October—one morning in August 1981, I caught a 19 pound, ten-ounce and a 20 pound, ten ounce bluefish not much more than an hour apart—people weren’t complaining too much.  There was also a quality weakfish bite; in that same August 1981, three of us ran over to Eaton’s Neck one evening, and caught 13 weakfish between 7 and 14 pounds in about an hour and a half (my friend caught the latter fish on 4-pound line and would have had the line class record at the time, had we realized that the existing record was just over 12 before the fish was filleted). 

In the spring and, particularly, in the fall, we were seeing some of the best flounder fishing, and some of the largest flounder, that we had ever experienced, and if the blackfishing was declining a bit, the fluke fishing was only getting better, with a lot of decent fish around, and a few fluke in the double digits being caught by folks willing to take the ride across the Sound to Lloyd’s Neck.

So the fishing was OK from a shop’s perspective, so long as fishing was good enough to keep fishermen on the water.

But in recent years, that hasn’t been the case.

Striped bass abundance has been in decline since the mid-2000s, but that decline has become particularly noticeable over the past couple of years. Outside of a run of big fish that seem to exit the Hudson River around Memorial Day, and set up in deeper water off Bridgeport, striped bass fishing in the western Sound over the past few years hasn’t been good enough to keep anglers fishing as much as they once did, and bluefish are no longer abundant enough to take the place of the missing bass.  After blues were deemed to be overfished in 2019, a new rebuilding plan was put in place, and biologists claim that the stock is responding.  However, some folks I know who fish the western Sound on a regular basis tell me that they didn’t catch a single bluefish during the entire 2026 season, so where that rebuilding population is spending its time isn’t completely clear.

Blackfish abundance seems to be increasing, but most of the fish in the western Sound are too small for anglers to keep.  Almost all of the fluke being caught are also undersized.  The spring mackerel run, while the best in years, was still sparse by historical standards, and winter flounder have completely collapsed.

Just to get an idea of how the fishery has declined in the 17 years since the current owner purchased the shop, in 2009 Connecticut anglers caught an estimated one million bluefish (including young of the year “snappers”); in 2025, the estimated catch had dropped to just a little over 381,000.  During the same period, the striped bass catch fell from a little under 2.2 million fish to about 900,000.

Those were the two most important fish to Connecticut anglers in 2009, generating an estimated 257,039 directed trips and 1,158,673 directed trips, respectively, in that year.  Because both species willingly strike artificial lures, and are large enough to test an angler’s skill and tackle after being hooked, they also tend to generate higher levels of tackle sales.

But because the abundance of both species declined over the past 17 years, by 2025 the number of directed striped bass trips dropped to an estimated 696,197, while directed bluefish trips dropped to 103,852.  Those numbers are even low compared to just three years earlier, for in 2022, Connecticut anglers still made an estimated 887,345 trips targeting striped bass, and another 261,608 trips—very slightly more than in 2009—directly targeting bluefish.

The dropoff in just the past few trips has been very sharp.

The only fish that saw effort increase substantially was scup, which generated an estimated 169,293 directed trips in 2009 and 646,143 such trips 2025.  But as scup are nowhere near as abundant in the western Sound as they are farther east, and only require simple bait and tackle to catch—a package or two of frozen clams or squid, a few hooks, and some sinkers are about all one needs, that increase probably didn’t do the shop in Cos Cob much good, and almost certainly didn’t come close to offsetting the losses from the decline in trips targeting striped bass and bluefish.

So yes, poor fishing can have a real impact on the health, and even the very survival, of tackle shops and other angling-related businesses.  It is sad that the shop in Cos Cob, which had endured through more than six decades and multiple owners, will be brought down by something that was completely avoidable—poor fishing—if managers had buckled down and just done their jobs.

But it is sadder yet that so many other shops, as well as the organization that is supposed to represent them, is setting the stage for more failures, as they oppose needed management measures and, in some cases, even call for the relaxing of regulations needed to rebuild and conserve important fish stocks.

Yet so long as they fight to allow short-term economic concerns to trump the long-term health and sustainability of the nation’s fish stocks, we can expect the failures to continue.

 

 

2 comments:

  1. Charlie I feel your emotions when you loose an old friend establishment and memories of your past
    Old haunts which will never be visited again
    And the great influences that inspired your youth yrs ago
    Most doesn’t ever have the great operrunity to have thoses moments in time
    Charlie at least we have them to recall

    ReplyDelete
  2. Charlie, first even though we are of a different persuasion i certainly enjoy your perspective....primarily because our timeline seems parallel. Anyway i started commercial fishing outta Hatteras in 1976/77 and stripped bass was one of my first and most lucrative endeavors. Ironically a few month's back i just cut the last of that gear....10" outta line. It was so old the top line was rotten..... But since then....ALOT has changed! Hatteras used to primarily be their southern boundary. We had a fishery that lasted 5/7 years depending on your dependance from that date. Most of us found other far more predominant species to target. But no different than the striped bass.....they too no longer overwinter off our shores....at least appreciably! ALONG with a lot of other species. And the real question is CLIMATE CHANGE not as much a reason as the fishing pressure .....which i don't discount? Anyway, as a fisherman that has spent the last 50 years transitioning from one fishery to another during the season's.....THIS ONE IS FAR AND AWAY THE MOST PERPLEXING.......with this Super El Nino. Just saying! Our present King Mackerel season is the worst ever....at least in the last 50!

    ReplyDelete